As an inveterate list-keeper, I am always interested in comparisons between one time period and another, and between one place or culture and another.
In the past year a major establishment newspaper in the UK and one in the US both, within six months of one another, asked their readers a slight variant on the basic question - What were your favorite childhood books? The UK paper, The Daily Telegraph, ran their question January 17, 2008 and the US paper, The New York Times ran its question July 19, 2007. The Telegraph had 189 commenters leaving one or more suggestions. The New York Times had 1,031. The Telegraph readers identified 430 separate books that they recalled fondly from their childhoods whereas the larger number of Times' readers mentioned 977 separate titles.
The results are of course completely unscientific but, as is often the case, the less rigorous the method, the more interesting the speculative discussion arising. The Telegraph and the Times both occupy similar societal/journalistic positions as papers of record and probably are reasonably similar in terms of the income/education/professional occupation profiles of their readers. The Times' responses might have a slightly greater emphasis on fantasy and science fiction as the question was asked in the time period around the release of the final instalment of Harry Potter.
OK; enough caveats. Below are the results from the readers of the two papers. Listed first are the top twenty individual titles specifically mentioned by the readers in each country. There is then a second list of authors where readers indicated something along the lines of "All of Roald Dahl" or "Everything by Louisa May Alcott."
There are four titles that show up on both the UK and the US lists; The Chronicles of Narnia, The Hobbit, The Lord of the Rings, and Charlotte's Web. There are also four cross-over authors; Roald Dahl, Dr. Seuss, Enid Blyton and Isaac Asimov. I am amazed that Enid Blyton made it onto the top twenty list of authors on the Times' list. I can only speculate that a good number of Canadians must have snuck across the internet frontier to put in some votes. None-the-less it is interesting that the four cross-overs should represent two quintessentially American and two quintessentially English authors. Other surprises - Poe, Alcott, Milne, Nesbit, Andersen, Dickens, Kipling, Verne and C.S. Lewis each show up on only one list, and not even necessarily on that of their country of origin. Hmmm.
In the past year a major establishment newspaper in the UK and one in the US both, within six months of one another, asked their readers a slight variant on the basic question - What were your favorite childhood books? The UK paper, The Daily Telegraph, ran their question January 17, 2008 and the US paper, The New York Times ran its question July 19, 2007. The Telegraph had 189 commenters leaving one or more suggestions. The New York Times had 1,031. The Telegraph readers identified 430 separate books that they recalled fondly from their childhoods whereas the larger number of Times' readers mentioned 977 separate titles.
The results are of course completely unscientific but, as is often the case, the less rigorous the method, the more interesting the speculative discussion arising. The Telegraph and the Times both occupy similar societal/journalistic positions as papers of record and probably are reasonably similar in terms of the income/education/professional occupation profiles of their readers. The Times' responses might have a slightly greater emphasis on fantasy and science fiction as the question was asked in the time period around the release of the final instalment of Harry Potter.
OK; enough caveats. Below are the results from the readers of the two papers. Listed first are the top twenty individual titles specifically mentioned by the readers in each country. There is then a second list of authors where readers indicated something along the lines of "All of Roald Dahl" or "Everything by Louisa May Alcott."
There are four titles that show up on both the UK and the US lists; The Chronicles of Narnia, The Hobbit, The Lord of the Rings, and Charlotte's Web. There are also four cross-over authors; Roald Dahl, Dr. Seuss, Enid Blyton and Isaac Asimov. I am amazed that Enid Blyton made it onto the top twenty list of authors on the Times' list. I can only speculate that a good number of Canadians must have snuck across the internet frontier to put in some votes. None-the-less it is interesting that the four cross-overs should represent two quintessentially American and two quintessentially English authors. Other surprises - Poe, Alcott, Milne, Nesbit, Andersen, Dickens, Kipling, Verne and C.S. Lewis each show up on only one list, and not even necessarily on that of their country of origin. Hmmm.
| UK (The Daily Telegraph) |
USA (The New York Times) |
| The Chronicles of Narnia | Nancy Drew |
| Swallows and Amazons | Lord of the Rings |
| Alice in Wonderland | The Chronicles of Narnia |
| Peter Rabbit | The Little House on the Prairie |
| Treasure Island | The Hardy Boys |
| The Hobbit | A Wrinkle in Time |
| Lord of the Rings | Anne of Green Gables |
| Wind in the Willows | Little Women |
| Black Beauty | Tom Swift |
| Winnie-the-Pooh | The Hobbit |
| The Magic Faraway Tree | The Wizard of Oz |
| Robinson Crusoe | The Phantom Toll Booth |
| Famous Five | Charlotte's Web |
| The Silver Sword | The Bobbsey Twins |
| Harry Potter | Black Stallion |
| Biggles | The Secret Garden |
| Lord of the Flies | The Dark is Rising |
| Aesop's Fables | The Mixed Up Files of Mrs. Basil E. Frankweiler |
| The Diary of a Young Girl | The Boxcar Children |
| Charlotte's Web | Dr. Dolittle |
| UK (The Daily Telegraph) |
USA (The New York Times) |
| Enid Blyton | Judy Blume |
| C.S. Lewis | Roald Dahl |
| Arthur Ransome | Beverly Cleary |
| Beatrix Potter | Robert Heinlein |
| Roald Dahl | Isaac Asimov |
| Aesop | Jules Verne |
| Rudyard Kipling | Dr. Seuss |
| Willard Price | Ray Bradbury |
| William Shakespeare | Enid Blyton |
| Charles Dickens | Jack London |
| E. Nesbit | Louisa May Alcott |
| Hans Christian Andersen | Mark Twain |
| Malcolm Saville | Albert Payson Terhune |
| R.L. Stevenson | Madeline L'Engle |
| Captain Marryat | Edward Eager |
| Dr. Seuss | L.M. Montgomery |
| G.A. Henty | A.A. Milne |
| H. Rider Haggard | Agatha Christie |
| Isaac Asimov | Edgar Allan Poe |
| Jacqueline Wilson | John Bellairs |
Thanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)
(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)